BMAD-METHOD/expansion-packs/bmad-creative-writing/tasks/critical-review.md

------------------------------------------------------------

Critical Review Task

------------------------------------------------------------

---

task: id: critical-review name: Critical Review description: Comprehensive professional critique using critic-review-tmpl and rubric checklist. persona_default: book-critic inputs:

• manuscript file (e.g., draft-manuscript.md or chapter file) steps:
• If audience/genre not provided, prompt user for details.
• Read manuscript (or excerpt) for holistic understanding.
• Fill critic-review-tmpl with category scores and commentary.
• Execute checklists/critic-rubric-checklist to spot omissions; revise output if any boxes unchecked.
• Present final review to user. output: critic-review.md ...