# Critique Report: [FEATURE NAME]

**Date**: [DATE]
**Feature**: [Link to spec.md]
**Plan**: [Link to plan.md]
**Verdict**: [✅ PROCEED / ⚠️ PROCEED WITH UPDATES / 🛑 RETHINK]

---

## Executive Summary

[One-paragraph assessment of the spec and plan quality, key strengths, and primary concerns from both product and engineering perspectives.]

---

## Product Lens Findings 🎯

### Problem Validation
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| P1 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### User Value Assessment
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| P2 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Alternative Approaches
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| P3 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Edge Cases & UX
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| P4 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Success Measurement
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| P5 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

---

## Engineering Lens Findings 🔧

### Architecture Soundness
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E1 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Failure Mode Analysis
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E2 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Security & Privacy
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E3 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Performance & Scalability
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E4 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Testing Strategy
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E5 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Operational Readiness
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E6 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

### Dependencies & Integration
| ID | Severity | Finding | Suggestion |
|----|----------|---------|------------|
| E7 | 🎯/💡/🤔 | [finding] | [suggestion] |

---

## Cross-Lens Insights 🔗

Items where both product and engineering perspectives converge:

| ID | Finding | Product Impact | Engineering Impact | Suggestion |
|----|---------|---------------|-------------------|------------|
| X1 | [finding] | [product concern] | [engineering concern] | [unified suggestion] |

---

## Findings Summary

| Metric | Count |
|--------|-------|
| 🎯 Must-Address | [count] |
| 💡 Recommendations | [count] |
| 🤔 Questions | [count] |
| Product findings | [count] |
| Engineering findings | [count] |
| Cross-lens findings | [count] |

---

## Recommended Actions

### 🎯 Must-Address (Before Proceeding)
1. **[ID]**: [Action with specific file and change description]

### 💡 Recommendations (Strongly Suggested)
1. **[ID]**: [Action]

### 🤔 Questions (Need Stakeholder Input)
1. **[ID]**: [Question requiring clarification]

---

**Severity Legend**:
- 🎯 **Must-Address**: Blocks proceeding to implementation
- 💡 **Recommendation**: Strongly suggested improvement
- 🤔 **Question**: Needs stakeholder input to resolve

---

*Generated by `/speckit.critique` — Dual-lens strategic and technical review for spec-driven development.*